Wheel Proportions !

Contains formal style discussions relating to VWs and other automobiles.

Moderator: Maraschino Larry

Wheel Proportions !

Postby Maraschino Larry » Fri Feb 20, 2009 11:59 pm

Hi!

So I was driving around today barely conscious thinking about wheels (I know, what else is new?), and I got to thinking about how certain wheels in different (diameter) sizes can change so much. There are in fact many wheels that I love in X diameter but hate in Y.

fig 1. Borbet type T

14" - :love:
Image

16" - always tidy
Image

17" - what are those ASAs? ah, who cares?
Image


fig 2. Schmidt TH line

13-15" - wheel nirvana
13"
Image
14"
Image
15"
Image

16" - Gross. This is a totally subjective (as is everything) of course, but I am ashamed to call these THs. This pic illustrates just how much the proportions of the wheel change. Contrast to the 15" above as well. Only 1" taller!
Image

17"- It doesn't get any better here...
Image

18" - The look of the face is so warped at this point that I have found myself almost coming full circle with these in the right application... like this Passat. But it isn't love in the same way that the 13-15"s tickle my innards.
Image


fig 3. BBS RS

14" - These are hella rare. I feel they exemplify everything classic and sexy about the design.
Image

we all know what 15" and 16" centers look like... always fresh.

17" - still tippin'
Image

18" - This is where it starts getting strange. Some people dislike the look of the big lips that use the 17" centers. Personally it doesn't bother me.
Image

Or you can have the super RS where the centres get distorted.
Image

These are sort of like the 18" THs to me... kinda cool but it's not really an RS.


If you haven't noticed, as the size increases it seems to have the inverse effect on stylishness. Why is this? Is it because these all started as smaller wheels and something gets lost in translation when they want to make a larger version? Iunno. You tell me.

Along this vein, ever notice how replica wheels, especially Porsche, always look retarded if they're 5x100 with exposed lugs?
Image
vs.
Image

This again throws off proportions! Amazing. Please share anything pertinent :)
.**CLUB.**
**.*SODA**.*

tripwalking wrote:I'd be willing to split it straight up the crotch.
User avatar
Maraschino Larry
 
Posts: 8907
Joined: Sat May 27, 2006 12:57 pm
Location: HybridAyr

Re: Wheel Proportions !

Postby Dreamstate » Sat Feb 21, 2009 12:48 am

haha.. i was thinking the same thing with the THs.. could do without ever seeing 16s and 17s.. but then suddenly i see 18s and i like them again.

The Super RS really don't do anything for me, I think as a general rule for me, I like to see lots of barrel/lip (not necessarily dish) for a multipiece wheel.
Mercedes-Benz. The Cadillac of automobiles.
User avatar
Dreamstate
 
Posts: 7616
Joined: Tue Aug 08, 2006 9:56 pm
Location: Kitchener, Ontario


Return to Styling Discussions

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest